Android Question StartActivity followed by Activity.Finish

Erel

B4X founder

Staff member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 21, 2013

• #2

It is most probably not related to the Activity.Finish call.

Try to start the activity with CallSubDelayed instead of StartActivity.

There are cases where Android ignores the intent (it happens when you switch between several activities quickly). CallSubDelayed will retry to start the activity several times.

B4X:

CallSubDelayed(name_of_new_activity, "any sub you like")
Activity.Finish

 

Upvote 0

mc73

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 21, 2013

• #3

I've never experienced such behavior. Under which sub type are you setting these commands?

 

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 22, 2013

• #4

The behavior can easily be reproduced by the attached program. If you click slowly on the buttons, everything works okay. As soon as you tap a little faster, the initial screen appears again (which should normally NEVER happen if you follow the logic of the program).

I have the impression that callsubdelayed does not change anything, but Erel might find a better solution to circumvent this problem...

 

Attachments

• finishbug.zip

  6.6 KB · Views: 515

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 22, 2013

• #5

This is the version with CallSubDelayed: exactly the same result! The "unwanted" activity pops up when you click fast on the buttons.

 

Attachments

• finishbug.zip

  6.6 KB · Views: 429

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 22, 2013

• #6

...and adding an animation on the screen makes things even worse. See the attached source code. You can flip between the two screens exactly ONCE. The next flip fails... ALWAYS!

Either a bug in B4A, or in Android, or... something else I don't see?

 

Attachments

• finishbug.zip

  6.3 KB · Views: 486

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 24, 2013

• #7

No one with a reasonable explanation?

 

Upvote 0

Erel

B4X founder

Staff member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 24, 2013

• #8

I've tried the app in post #5. I didn't see anything strange. It toggles between screen1 to screen2.

 

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 24, 2013

• #9

Please try the example from post 6. The one from post 5 only fails when you click on the buttons really quick. The example from post 6 fails ALL the time on my mobile.

 

Upvote 0

Erel

B4X founder

Staff member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 24, 2013

• #10

Have you tried it with CallSubDelayed?

 

Upvote 0

mc73

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 24, 2013

• #11

I've tried both examples, no such thing happens. What's your testing device?

 

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 25, 2013

• #12

HTC Desire
Android 2.3.3

Erel, I have the same file attached with CallSubDelayed this time. The problem is the same: I can click once on the button to launch screen2, go back to the main screen, but clicking on the button to show screen2 once again results in an application exit.

 

Attachments

• finishbug.zip

  6.3 KB · Views: 497

Upvote 0

Erel

B4X founder

Staff member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 25, 2013

• #13

It might be a problem with your device. I've tested it, pressing as quickly as possible on the buttons and it works fine.

 

Upvote 0

M

Mahares

Expert

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 25, 2013

• #14

I tested your app on 2 devices. Here are my findings:
1. A device with OS 4.0.3. The app behaves exactly as Wimpie reported. It exits the app on 2nd click.
2. A device with OS 4.2.2. The app works as it was supposed to without exiting and as reported by Erel.

 

Upvote 0

Erel

B4X founder

Staff member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Nov 25, 2013

• #15

Try to remove the call to Activity.Finish and see whether it works.

 

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Jun 6, 2014

• #16

Once I remove Activity.Finish, the app works. But not the way I want. I *absolutely* need to finish the activity. This "bug" seems to be related to "older" versions of Android, I cannot reproduce it on 4.2.2 (as confirmed before by Mahares). Desperately looking for a workaround for older versions.

 

Upvote 0

wimpie3

Well-Known Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Jun 6, 2014

• #17

It seems that the bug is gone when I add this to the manifest:

B4X:

SetActivityAttribute(main, android:launchMode, "singleInstance")

 

Upvote 0

alan dodd

Member

Licensed User

Longtime User

• Apr 10, 2015

• #18

Hello, wimpie3. Just for info: I can confirm the exact behavour as you describe it:

with android 4.0.3 (on a dolphin black 60E Honeywell) it exits on 2nd click
with android 5.02 (on htc one) it works forever

with android 4.0.3 adding the line you mentioned to the manifest, it works forever

regards, Alan

 

Upvote 0