Discussion in 'Chit Chat' started by LucaMs, Apr 10, 2019.
um... thanks to the huge funding... they probably used Blender.
They spent umpteen millions to get a picture that looks like a blurry Jammie Dodger biscuit. Why ?
looks like a heatmap of a fresh baked greeze vaporizing donut.
I wonder how it is possible to look that far from here.
When you move your telescope 1/1000th of a cm you are billions of km away from your last 'shot' at that distance.
Maybe we can ask Dr Disillussion to debunk the myth
I am wondering why people spend billions to take a photo for a place they would never go.
Another thing, if light's reached us after millions of years, then the photo is already useless.
To determine if theories about black holes are correct?
How is the past useless? Again, one can confirm/revise/put to rest theories about black holes, about the creation of the universe, etc.
AFAIK, that's not a real photo, which couldn't be taken anyway due to the nature of a blackhole.
What we're observing is kind of an interpolation of a huge amount of data collected by some telescopes on Earth. So, it's most a representation of a blackhole than a real blackhole.
The exitement is mostly due to the fact they prove the existence of something called blackhole, a gigantic one. It's more like telling ourselves "we are on the right path" than "look, this is a BH".
Who tells us that the "scientists" have not enjoyed the billionaire funds to then give to us... a simple graphic image created using a PC?
[Not really a great example but, and I turn to @udg, it's a bit like the Rousseau platform... who tells you that the final result is the real one?]
The real utility would be to be able to throw some people in some black hole
I do hope this was sarcasm...
You are a good believer Oliver : )
That was sarcastic comment
Looks like my sarcasm detector is broken...
This is the secret of how they did the black hole photo.
How to take a picture of a black hole | Katie Bouman (TED)
Using a billion words... she showed that with billionaire funding it is possible to... create an image of what a black hole looks like... presumably.
That (built) image is almost as useful as this one:
the photo is blured and out of focus.. the bilionaire should denand a refund.
I think the image looks more like my favourite snack call "Super Ring" which produced in my country. It looks like Cheezels.
They use black hole theories to get an image from the raw data that proves the validity of the black hole theories.