CustomDialog and Events

canalrun · Jun 19, 2012

Hello,
I am trying to use the CustomDialog to create a modal dialog box. I am using Classes in B4A 2.0 – really neat.

I have a Panel (p1) that contains a ScrollView. The ScrollView is populated with 20 or so labels (that scroll vertically). If a person clicks on a label I want it to trigger a click event.

If I add p1 to the Activity, my click events trigger when a label is tapped.

With identical code only adding p1 instead to a CustomDialog, visually it shows properly and the modal-ness works, but tapping on a label does not fire the click events.

When using the CustomDialog I can scroll the labels vertically within the ScrollView so I know there's not an invisible panel capturing touch events.

Any idea why label click events do not fire when using the CustomDialog?

Thanks,
Barry.

Erel · Jun 20, 2012

Can you upload your project?

canalrun · Jun 20, 2012

Erel said:
Can you upload your project?

Hello,
Thanks for looking at this

This test app shows a File Dialog.

It is currently configured in what I call "CustomDialog" mode. To change it to "Activity" mode several lines of code need to be commented. I did it this way to show that it is essentially using the same code.

To have the program run in "Activity" mode, in the FileDlg module (which is a class – thanks) comment the three lines of code near lines 278, 279, and 280 in the Show sub.

It's also handy to put a breakpoint at line 290 (in the FDpn_Click sub) in the FileDlg module to see if the "file label" event fires in response to a click on a file or directory name within the ScrollView.

For me, this event fires when in "Activity" mode but does not fire when I am in "CustomDialog" mode. The ScrollView does scroll in both modes.

Barry.

Erel · Jun 21, 2012

You only uploaded the class module. I think that it is not possible to handle events while a modal dialog is displayed (not 100% sure).

agraham · Jun 21, 2012

In the DialogsDemo Custom and Custom2 show a button in a CustomDialog handling a Click event while the dialog is displayed.

canalrun · Jun 21, 2012

Erel said:
You only uploaded the class module. I think that it is not possible to handle events while a modal dialog is displayed (not 100% sure).

In the DialogsDemo Custom and Custom2 show a button in a CustomDialog handling a Click event while the dialog is displayed.

Sorry. I don't know I got a zip file with only one file. But I have uploaded a new zip with the entire test project directory. (I used the export function and triple checked this time).

Agraham, yes I have looked at the demo and most of the prior posts asking similar questions. The demo does work on my devices. I pretty much copied the code I use directly from the demo. The fact that it works there and not here is confusing.

Thanks,
Barry.

agraham · Jun 21, 2012

I don't understand your code but if I put something like

ToastMessageShow("btFDOk_Click", True)

in each of your click events then I can see that they are being called OK.

canalrun · Jun 21, 2012

agraham said:
I don't understand your code but if I put something like

ToastMessageShow("btFDOk_Click", True)

in each of your click events then I can see that they are being called OK.

Thanks. I've added ToastMessages to all my Click event subroutines. I've also added a screenshot from my Samsung Vibrant to the zip file.

On both my Samsung Vibrant (Android V2.2) and my Acer A500 (Android V4.03) none of my click events fire; no ToastMessages show. The significant click events are for 1. the up arrow at the top, 2. clicking on any of the lines in the ScrollView to select a file or move to a directory, and 3. my two buttons "Ok" and "Cancel". The two buttons from the Custom Dialog, "Ok" and "Cancel", at the bottom both work on my devices. If I get the CustomDialog to work I will remove my Ok and Cancel buttons since they will be redundant.

If in your testing the ToastMessages display upon clicking, that will be interesting.

If I comment out the three lines 278, 279, and 280, then re-compile and re-run, this removes the CustomDialog. Now all my events fire properly on my devices and the ToastMessages show, but I lose Modal-ness, which I really like.

Thanks,
Barry.

agraham · Jun 21, 2012

Sorry :sign0161: I missed that in FileDlg3 you had commented out those three lines and it was in "Activity mode". I also don't get the events fired when in "Modal mode". I don't know why as the events from a modal dialog in the CustomDialogs demo works fine with Basic4android 2.0 so I can only surmise the failure is something to do with them being located in a Class.

Erel · Jun 21, 2012

I will check it.

canalrun · Jun 23, 2012

I can only surmise the failure is something to do with them being located in a Class.

I will check it.

Thanks. I modified my test application to not use classes. The same problem happens in "CustomDialog" mode. The events for my buttons or tapping within the ScrollView do not fire. I then commented out the three lines changing the test application to "Activity" mode – no CustomDialog. My button click and Scroll View taps now fire.

I have attached both versions, "CustomDialog" and "Activity", of the test application that does not use classes. Do you get the same results?

Barry.

agraham · Jun 24, 2012

canalrun said:
Do you get the same results?

Yes. Custom Dialog itself does nothing to aid (or otherwise) the propagation of events. It seems odd to me that some work and some apparently don't but I don't fully understand the Basic4android modal code and its relationship to Android messaging to explain it. I guess only Erel would have the necessary insight if he can be bothered to shine his intellect upon it!

Erel · Jun 24, 2012

I haven't missed this thread. I need to investigate before I can answer on this one...

agraham · Jun 24, 2012

Sunrise!

Erel · Jun 25, 2012

The Activity is considered to be paused until Activity_Create is completed. While the activity is paused most events will not be processed. If you check the unfiltered logs you will see a message saying: ignoring event x.

The solution is simple. You should show the dialog in Activity_Resume.

agraham · Jun 25, 2012

'Simples!'

(if you don't understand it's a UK cultural reference)

I should have noticed that it was shown in Activity_Create as I've been caught by that before.

Erel · Jun 25, 2012

Note that another option is to use CallSubDelayed:

B4X:

Sub Activity_Create(FirstTime As Boolean)
   CallSubDelayed(Me, "ShowDialog")
End Sub

Sub ShowDialog
  FDInitialize(Activity)
  FDShow("")
End Sub

This can be useful if you do not want to call it in Activity_Resume for some reason.

canalrun · Jun 25, 2012

Erel said:
Note that another option is to use CallSubDelayed:

...

This can be useful if you do not want to call it in Activity_Resume for some reason.

Thank you. This is good information to have. I implemented opening the file dialog in response to a button click instead of within the Activity Create module. My events now fire as expected from within the Custom Dialog.

Barry.

dexMilano · Dec 13, 2013

Hello all,
I'm restarting this topic because I think I have a similar problem.
I've a button that opens a custom dialog with a scroll view that should be updated every tap on inself.
It seems that taps are not executed when the dialog is opened.
When I close it the events are fired.
But this is not useful because the content of the listview should be updated in the dialog.

Thanks

dex

CustomDialog and Events

Well-Known Member

B4X founder

Well-Known Member

Attachments

B4X founder

Expert

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Expert

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Expert

B4X founder

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Expert

B4X founder

Expert

B4X founder

Expert

B4X founder

Well-Known Member

Active Member